‘Hife & Daw’!(courtesy: T.T.N.) fart session between me and paedo.It was some time ago that I heard a song which goes something like this “ if you do Friday night right, then there is no Saturday………bla bla” . But after listening to that song I have ended up wasting most of the Friday nights in pursuit to make it right. Anyways, last Friday night I realized the true potential a fart session holds and its sheer power to enlighten a person./*for those who are not aware about the actual meaning of fart session in IIT, our group discussions are referred as fart sessions for obvious, BUT NOT LITERAL, reasons.
This is about a fart session me and paedo had last Friday night. We started
discussion about the most arbit scenes of Mithun’s movie and how everyone used to appreciate the things which we find ridiculous now. The movie Disco dancer, songs like “ ud gaya kabootarwaaaa“ etc. Then, I don’t remember how exactly we started discussing Military power of USA and how much more powerful it is than rest of the world. After having a discussion which sounded like a plot of a sci-fi film, we started discussing diplomacy, world affairs on world stage and whether military prowess is more powerful than diplomacy. Well, that eventually led us to discussion about lobbying by Jews in US and how it affects the US policy towards Arab nations. This eventually led to an argument that Islam and Christianity are basically missionary religions and their aim is to spread itself, which always include war, both defense and attack. So basically what is happening today between Arabs and Christians is because of the wrong foundations. Well this discussion about lobbying took us to lobbying by industries and since I was having a discussion with Paedo so it didn’t take time for us to involve bio-tech industries. It didn’t take much time further to exclude all the other industries!
The rest session is very long and confusing if written in a paragraph form. So I will write it in a dialogue format.
Paedo: You know that the Bio-tech industries are the ones who lobby the govt. to ban neo-research in the field because if every thing is allowed then most of these companies will become out-dated while they blink their eyes.
Erectus (Me): Well! If its important for a industry’s survival to lobby and get things done by unscrupulous means then we should have nothing against it because lot of people and families are dependent on it.
Paedo: Like, recently when Bush banned steam cell research, his actions was more based on pressure from industry itself than on ethics ground.
Erectus: People have countered this ethics ideology by saying that what about those cells which are cultivated in lab and about 2/3 rd of them are disposed because they are not used.
Paedo: Do you think it should be allowed.
Erectus: Yes, because it has not taken the actual form of a life. We have created it and the possibility of this 7 celled structure eventually leading to a human life is created by us and not GOD.
At this moment I was not speaking about emotions and consciousness which later formed the base of my argument.
Paedo, at 4AM was too active to loose this chance.
Paedo fires: Then the concept of the movie” The Island” is justified where clones of human are developed in accelerated growth medium to serve as source of organs for the “Natural Human”. These clones, when later found that they can not survive without society, where placed in a confinement which replicates a society and are made to believe about a fictional epidemic on earth. They are told about the only island free of epidemic and these people, who are made to meet demands, are going to be placed on that island, while actually they are taken to an operation theatre. These people believing what they are told are actually very happy while leaving and their friends are also happy about them.
So this thing should be allowed or not?
Erectus: No, this is similar to sedating a”natural human” and taking his organs out for those who can pay.
Paedo: But in this case his family is left alone and in pain.
Erectus: You cannot fool a person and serve your purpose and call it ethical.
Paedo: But that human is not natural, God had not created a place for him. We created him for our use.
Erectus: Just because you created him, it doesn’t mean that you can meddle with his life. He has a story about his life; he has lived and felt his surroundings. You have no right to alter his surroundings so that it serves as a stock of organs for you rather than a human being.
Paedo: So why is it right to cultivate an E-coli and use it for research. It also is a living form, it has life, it responds to surroundings and it is well aware of its surroundings.
Erectus: Biological awareness is different from emotional awareness. Body is different from mind, or lets say body is different from emotions. Our body is aware to many things which “we” are not aware of and it responds to the surroundings in many ways which we don’t control.
Paedo: What emotions are u talking about? How can u say that a bacteria does not have emotions.
Erectus: By emotions I mean emotional consciousness. For ex: if I see a beggar on a road side, moaning with pain and if I couldn’t help him at that moment, then I will feel bad about this, even though I m not attached to him, I am not dependent on him. This emotion, it is not biological, it’s because I am conscious.
Paedo: You know that there is a plasma transfer mechanism in bacteria where a bacteria transfers a huge part of it’s plasma to other members of the colony, even though he won’t gain anything from that bacteria.
Erectus: But he will get from the colony when he is in need. To be a part of colony he needs to sacrifice today. It’s a symbiosis rather than emotion.
Paedo: Well! Symbiosis is not the word as it represents mutual dependence between two different species.
Erectus: Don’t take the argument towards definitions. You understood what I wanted to convey. Neways, the colony of bacteria has some rules which help it survive and evolve.
Paedo: Then the emotion you have for that beggar is the result of your upbringing in a human society which has laid out certain rules to help itself evolve. These rules include that its members should be compassionate towards each other.
At this point I was about to submit to the argument that emotions are biological and even lowest form of life have emotions. Then, out of nowhere, a term made its acquaintance in the discussion, “ Higher level of emotions”.
Erectus: If emotions are biological in root sense, then it is unethical to cultivate a life form with this high level of emotions, for research or used as stocks or organs. These higher levels of emotions are what we are concerned, because those “ lower form of emotions” are just a biological response of life to its surroundings, while the” higher level of emotions” are the ones that differentiates ethical and unethical in this case.
Paedo: So cultivating guinea pig for research and dissecting them is ethical because they lack this higher level of emotions. Even cultivating other animals is ethical because they lack these higher levels of emotions.
Erectus: Who says that these animals don’t have higher level of emotions? The level may vary, but they are there.
Paedo: Other animals may have but guinea pig…..they don’t have them.
Erectus: It’s because they are grown in a secluded and modified surrounding. What if I keep a guinea pig in this hostel, won’t it become a pet. Now, a pet definitely has higher level of emotions which are not a result of symbiosis. For example a dog, which is well fed by its owner, wags his tail when u look at him and pamper him affectionately.
Paedo: You seem to start countering yourself. You said that guinea pig can be cultivated and used for research, without disturbing the peace of ethical nerds.
This is bound to happen in any long fart session (Ya! We have been talking for two hours by then and usually it’s difficult to maintain coherence between your starting points and the points u make at the end of discussion). Clearly,a lot of dynamics is involved. From thermodynamics point of view, the energy involved from discussion melts icebergs of earlier opinions, volcanoes form new islands of opinions and knowledge. That is why this fart sessions are so important to any human being, or lets say for any living form with” higher level of emotions”!.
Lets continue…….
Erectus: I think there is confusion and let me state my final stand. I cannot guarantee that it conforms to my first stand. I am against cultivation of life forms which have higher levels of emotions, for research purposes. The line separating higher levels of emotions from biological emotions is decided from our present knowledge and not from our assumptions. We are supposed to act on our present knowledge. That restrains cultivating guinea pig for research and allows cultivation of E-coli for research as ethical. If we are cloning human being, that once it gains the higher level of emotions, we should not use it as stack of organs or research purpose, but this does not relieves us from the responsibility of seeing to it that he/she is taken care of till it becomes self-reliant.
Paedo: My stand is that cultivation of any living form for research is ethical, as god has not created place for it and we are the ones who introduced it in this universe. We should not bifurcate living form into ones that can be cultivated for research and ones that cannot, on the basis of a line, higher emotion and biological emotion line, about which we have no detailed and specific knowledge. So if we are allowing E-coli, we should allow humans too for being cultivated for research purpose.
Summary (in a very dramatic way by Paedo): Some people believe in a line, based on the level of emotions present in a living form, which defines cultivation of it for research as ethical and unethical. While other contends that we have no knowledge about the line and either it’s ethical or unethical for all life forms together.
Well! That eventually led us to have first Saturday’s breakfast of the semester.
I wrote this blog because I felt that it was too interesting to be lost in the past and I felt an urgent need to write it somewhere and found this blog to be a perfect place.
PS: @ Paedo-> If you find any discrepancies in the details, go and fuck yourself as I wrote it and things are bound to go my way in return for the pains I took to write it. Anyways, u can use the comments column to crib!